Daily Thought

It is not so much that we need to be taken out of exile. It is that the exile must be taken out of us. —The Rebbe

Reprinted from 365 Meditations of the Rebbe by Tzvi Freeman

Home arrow Topics arrow Inspiration arrow The difference between destructive and constructive sadness

The difference between destructive and constructive sadness Print E-mail
Yanki Tauber   
"There is nothing as whole as a broken heart", "Depression is not a sin; but what depression does, no sin can do" (Chassidic Sayings). Is sad bad?

Chassidic teaching differentiates between two types of sorrow: merirut, a constructive grief, and atzvut, a destructive grief. Merirut is the distress of one who not only recognizes his failings but also cares about them; one who agonizes over the wrongs he has committed, over his missed opportunities, over his unrealized potential; one who refuses to become indifferent to what is deficient in himself and his world. Atzvut is the distress of one who has despaired of himself and his fellow man, whose melancholy has drained him of hope and initiative. Merirut is a springboard for self-improvement; atzvut is a bottomless pit.

How does one distinguish between the two? The first is active, the second—passive. The first one weeps, the second’s eyes are dry and blank. The first one’s mind and heart are in turmoil, the second’s are still with apathy and heavy as lead. And what happens when it passes, when they emerge from their respective bouts of grief? The first one springs to action: resolving, planning, taking his first faltering steps to undo the causes of his sorrow. The second one goes to sleep. (Based on Tanya, Ch. 31)

Reprinted with permission from The Week In Review

Comments (1)add comment

anon said:

But what for someone who truly has no perspective - is such a person (especially when he or she is someone with great dreams and potential)doomed to live with this grief for as long as his or her circumstances last (or change in a miraculous way)? And why would Hashem endow some with vision, while simultaneously place them in a situation that makes it impossible to do anything with it? Or it should be by breaking other laws or commitment of Hashem, which cannot ber an option?
 
report abuse
vote down
vote up
September 29, 2007
Votes: +0

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 
Next >
Japan
I have been searching for connection within the ouen-chin tribe of japan, c...
Overcoming Self Imposed Limitations
Thanks for this allegories. Here's one of my own... In an old decrepit b...
The Pathans
I m pashtoon I want to share something related to pashtoon and Jews. it is ...
A Taste of Future - A Comprehensive review of Signs of Moshiach That We Are Witnessing Today
of course the gentile fits in. you guys will enjoy the peeace and prosperit...